SkinSAFE continuously monitors the news and research findings on products to help consumers make the most informed decisions about products for sensitive skin.
On May 25th, a report released by the analytical laboratory VALISURE concluded that chemical benzene was found in sunscreen. Organic, inorganic, and combination sun-filtering products were on the list as well as some after sunburn products. In total, over a dozen brands were listed and scientists and shoppers everywhere said, “WHAT IS GOING ON?”
VALISURE may be new to you, but they have been analyzing products for quite a while. You may have heard about them prior since they are the same group who found benzene in some hand sanitizing products during the coronavirus pandemic and the same company that detected the carcinogenic substance NDMA in every brand of ranitidine (brand name Zantac®) they tested.
Now, benzene was found in sunscreen. So, let’s break it down - what is benzene, what do the results mean, and what you – the sensitive skin shopper – need to know.
What Do We Know About Benzene?
Answer is simple…A LOT.
The Bad Stuff
So Benzene Is a “Baddy”, Why Is It Still Around?
Well, this one is complicated. See, as scientists, we have known that it was around us before benzene was found in sunscreen. It occurs as a gas and is both natural (yes, it IS a natural ingredient) and chemically produced. Forest fires produce it. Benzene is a natural part of gasoline, and it’s produced from cigarette smoke. Before you go all “e-cigarettes (vape products) are safer”, it has been found in those too. Glues, paints, waxes, and some industrial detergents (not your laundry detergents) can also contain benzene and release it upon use. In addition, benzene is still used in the manufacture and production of rubber, shoes, lubricants, some drugs, and dyes just to name a few.
In reality, you are being exposed to minute amounts of benzene every day because it occurs naturally, and some exposure is unavoidable. The EPA and other regulatory agencies do a great job policing the USA and place restrictions on both drinking water and the water which is found in rivers and lakes due to the rise in risk for leukemia. The use and exposure to benzene is monitored and Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) standards exist to protect us from exposure.
What Did VALISURE Find?
Simply put, benzene was found in sunscreens tested by VALISURE scientists. Seventy-eight products batches (think of this as bottles made at the same time) tested positive for benzene. Some products had levels higher than others, some products tested both positive and negative depending on the batch, and then some products never tested positive. Benzene was found in sunscreens with both chemical and mineral-based ingredients and in some after sun products. Over 55% of products that were positive for benzene were spray formulations, making us as scientist think about these results more than a few times.
How Did Benzene Get Into These Products?
At the time of the writing of this article, there does not appear to be a concrete reason for the results. The team at VALISURE has asked in a Citizen Petition for the US Food and Drug Administration (USFDA) to investigate since the presence and absence of benzene in these products was inconsistent and therefore not considered “unavoidable”. The USFDA is consulted since in the USA, sunscreens are considered drugs. Some sunscreens that sound similar to benzene like avobenzone, oxybenzone, and benzophenone-4 have not been shown to break down and trigger a positive test and are not at this point a reason for why benzene was found in sunscreen products.
Speculation has risen in social media and expert discussions as to the reason why benzene was found in sunscreen. Hypotheses include contamination of the supply chain of ingredients, lack of quality testing during production, use of solvents that contain benzene in cleaning and maintenance of the equipment, and even human error. VALISURE has called for the USFDA to issue a recall of the products implicated. Be aware, if (when) a recall is issued, it will likely only include those lots which tested positive. Think about recalls of foodstuffs like romaine lettuce, ground meat, etc. There will be a code for you to look for on the package. If you want to get a head start, a list of sunscreens, which tested negative for benzene, can be found online.
Should I Stop Wearing Sunscreen?
What Has SkinSAFE Done to Help?
Here are 5 (well 6) tips to live by for Sunscreen –
- Choose a sunscreen with an SPF of at least 30.
- Apply every 2 hours or more often if you sweat a lot or are in the water.
- Hats, umbrellas, and long sleeve shirts and pants help protect your skin – WEAR THEM.
- Be sure to apply enough sunscreen. 30 ml is what you’ll need for your entire body and between ¼ and ½ tsp for just your face (depends on the size of your head!)
- Replace your sunscreens like you do smoke detector batteries. Every Memorial Day.